Yesterday was my first attempt at potty training Kate. I had purchased "Potty Training in Less Than a Day" off amazon. I had read it, and I knew my stuff. I had all the supplies, a doll that wets, plenty of snacks and candy for positive reinforcement, and yummy drinks. Kate had passed all the readiness tests and we were good to go.
Or so I thought.
Successful pottys: 3 Accidents: 11
This day was FRUSTRATING! She was being so stubborn. She didn't want to obey at all, and she was so grumpy. She's been sick for the past few days, and even though she's feeling better I should've postponed training. But I still thought she could handle it! She did learn HOW to go potty though. So at least she did learn something. She can pull up and down her panties, sit on the potty, go (if I've timed it right), wipe, empty her potty bowl into the toilet, flush, and return her bowl to her potty. She's awesome at that. What I think her problem is bladder control. I don't think she recognizes the sensation of "having to pee" yet, because she would just go anywhere without even the slightest attempt to find the potty. She does know accidents are bad (we had 11!) and she always says, "Uh oh" and changes her panties. So she KNOWS accidents are bad, she KNOWS how to potty, but it's just not clicking.
So to avoid another incredibly stressful day like yesterday (she's already in a grumpy mood anyway), I've decided to go with a more gradual potty training approach. I just don't want her to have a bad experience with potty training and not want to do it at all. So I've put her back in diapers for the time being, and I'll take her potty every hour or so or when I think she needs to. Then in a couple weeks, I'll try a day of panties again. Hopefully this works.
My main goal is to have her completely trained by the time her little brother gets here. So I have 5 months, and I'm confident that she'll be trained way before then. She's a very independent little girl, so I know that as soon as it "clicks" she'll be good to go.
So, yes, I do recommend that book. And it will work, you just have to make sure your child is completely ready and in a good mood. Kate was neither, and I just tried it too soon.